InterVarsity Logo  
InterVarsity Store Search the Site Contact Us All InterVarsity Ministries
Student Leadership Journal  

You should know there's a new slj site! Check it out

The Accountability Factor

When Friends Fall: Confronting Sexual Sin

Sometimes, despite the most compassionate environment, the best teaching and the strongest accountability networks, students still find themselves caught up in sinful relationships. In the past several months I've encountered three situations in which friends have been involved in sexual sin. No matter how many times I've faced these issues, I've always felt heartbroken.

No situation like this is easy. How should we handle situations in which a friend or fellowship member is involved in sexual sin?

Why Confront?
It is paramount to remember that the purpose of confronting any kind of sin is always twofold: repentance and restoration. Repentance means coming to our loving Father acknowledging that our deliberate choices to disobey him have violated his trust, and that our rebellion against the family rules has placed a barrier between us and the One who loves us so deeply. We feel the weight of offending our Lord, and so we go to him, confessing our failures and our desire to live otherwise. We ask for-and receive-his lavish forgiveness.

The Christian community doesn't always handle the discovery of sin well-especially sexual sin. Too often when someone has confessed sin and repented of it they remain excluded from fellowship, marked as somehow unclean or lacking self-control. That's where restoration comes in. Our desire must always be to see our friends restored to fellowship, encouraged and upheld as they seek to walk in obedience.

But what if we discover a fellow believer in sin? And what if that person is reluctant to repent? Galatians 6:1 tells us, "Brothers, if someone is caught in a sin, you who are spiritual should restore him gently. But watch yourself, lest you also may be tempted." Gentleness and humility on our part is essential as we approach a friend to discuss an area of sin. Prior to approaching anyone, it will be important to spend time in prayer for yourself as well as for the individual(s) you intend to confront. Make sure that you are in good standing with the Lord (take the planks out of your own eyes) before you approach someone else (Matthew 7:1-5). Seek the Lord's perspective on the people involved as well as the activities in which they were involved.

The Approach
Scripture gives us a good outline of the process of going to a brother or sister who is in sin (Matthew 18:15-17). You begin by taking the person aside privately and bringing up the issues at hand. If he or she does not repent, then take someone else with you the next time you talk with them, probably your InterVarsity staff member. If the person still refuses to listen, then he or she is to be treated as a non-believer.

"As a non-believer?!" you might protest. "That sounds so abrupt and final." Perhaps it would be helpful to think through what following this process could look like in your fellowship:

After much prayer, you approach your friend and express your observations and concerns. If he or she admits that indeed there is sin involved and is willing to repent, then you have won back a brother or sister. Sometimes our friends (perhaps both partners of a couple) may be so entangled in sinful behavior that they feel trapped and unable to extricate themselves from the situation. You may be able to help by being supportive and encouraging, offering to hold them accountable for their time and actions in the future. Or you may find that they need more help than you can provide. Perhaps you can hold their hand as they go to a counselor or doctor for the first few visits. In every case, assure them of God's promise of forgiveness to those who repent (1 John 1:9). Spend time praying with your friends and commit to praying with them in the upcoming days, weeks, and months.

Unfortunately, things don't always go so well when confrontations occur. Your friends may be in a state of denial or of rebellion and might choose not to heed even the most loving of admonitions. If such is the case for you, now would be the time to talk with your I-V staff member. He or she can listen to your situation and pray with you, and then suggest how the two of you might go about talking with the people involved again. Most people will be struck by the severity of their situation once they are confronted a second time.

Treated as Non-believers
Although the initial reaction may be anger, students may welcome the care of friends who are looking out for their best. But God has given us the freedom to continue in sin and rebellion against him, and some people will choose to disregard all urging to repentance. This is where God calls us to treat them as non-believers. Now think: how are we to treat non-believers? Are we to reject them and cast them out? Not at all! We are to treat them with love and respect, desiring to see them relate rightly to God, praying for them, asking God to draw them to repentance, and sharing God's Word and promises with them. A friend's decision to continue in sin is not license to ignore them or treat them poorly. Would you treat a non-Christian friend so rudely?

Other Consequences
If someone entangled in sexual sin holds a leadership position in the fellowship, there may be other consequences as well. Your staff will have to work closely with the people involved to determine the best course of action in their situation. For some it may mean setting up accountability partnerships, for others it may mean stepping down from leadership so they can focus on "getting their house in order."

Avoiding Gossip
Throughout the process you should involve only those who need to know. By doing this you will avoid gossip and potentially explosive situations. Don't be premature in making announcements to the fellowship, or even to other leaders. Your first concern is for the individuals involved in the sinful relationship and then for the effects the relationship will have on the fellowship. It is embarrassing and frightening to stand before your peers and admit not only that you have sinned, but that you also need time out from leadership. For some, this may be a necessary part of the healing process, for others, this may only bury them with guilt and shame. Allow your staff worker to walk through the issues with those involved and to determine what will be best for them.

Extravagant Love
The thought of asking someone to step down from leadership leaves most of us with a knotted stomach and a very dry throat. Since we all sin, we fear being judgmental and hypocritical. In reality, under these circumstances, asking the people involved to step out of leadership is an incredibly loving thing to do-assuming that it's done out of love and in humility. The purpose of discipline is not to punish anyone, but rather to provide them with the opportunity to rebuild their relationship with Jesus.

While no one wants to go through the experience of confronting sexual sin, it can be a positive experience for everyone involved. View the situation as an opportunity to learn more about the Lord, yourself and the other person. Our God is extravagant in his love for us. In the same way, we must learn how to be extravagant in our love for others.
Valerie Gladu


Permission is granted to make and distribute verbatim copies of this article provided this permission notice, and the copyright notice below are preserved on all copies.
© 1995 InterVarsity Christian Fellowship of the USA. All rights reserved.
Back to main article


© 2004 InterVarsity Christian Fellowship/USA ®
Questions about the website? Contact Contact the webservant
Member of the International Fellowship of Evangelical Students
Gospel.com Community Member Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability